CHARTPOLICEChart Police

Crime taxonomy · Axes and scales

Truncated or non-zero baseline

Cutting off the bottom of a bar chart so small differences look huge.

What it looks like

The value axis of a bar, column or area chart starts somewhere above zero, or is broken without a clear marker. Readers compare bar lengths, so when the bottom is cut off a 1% difference can be drawn as a 6x difference.

Example

Example (Truncated or non-zero baseline): A 1.4 point gap (96.2% vs 94.8%) drawn as if the competitor were six times worse.TRUNCATED AXIS
The crime. A 1.4 point gap (96.2% vs 94.8%) drawn as if the competitor were six times worse.
The same data shown honestly: Starting at zero shows two nearly equal scores, and the title states the real gap.FIXED
The fix. Starting at zero shows two nearly equal scores, and the title states the real gap.

Why it is bad

How to fix it

  1. Start bar, column and area charts at zero.
  2. If the differences are what matter, plot the differences themselves, or use a dot plot or line chart.
  3. If you must break an axis, draw an unmistakable break marker and say so in the caption.
When it is not a crime. Line charts and dot plots do not encode values by length, so a non-zero axis is often the honest choice there (temperatures, interest rates, body weight).